Your car is hiding faults from you
Nick - Driven Forensics • 30 May 2025

Your car is hiding faults from you

Just because your car has recognised it has a fault, it doesn’t always mean a fault light will illuminate. Sometimes, your car waits for multiple faults of the same type before bringing a fault light or warning message on.


Where a fault is detected on a single occasion and it immediately brings a light or warning message on, it follows a one-trip fault logic (also known as one-trip detection logic). This logic is used in safety critical systems as well as those seriously affecting a vehicles emissions.


But there are other systems which follow a two-trip (or more) fault logic, where it requires the fault to be detected on multiple occasions before bringing a warning light or message on. These include non-critical emissions faults or minor faults on the engine or other systems which do not affect safety.


Why is this relevant to collision investigation?  Many people wrongly assume that if there are no lights on the dashboard, there must be no faults on the vehicle, but as we have seen, that’s not always true. This raises two items to consider.


The first is that in order to understand the health of a vehicle, it needs to be physically inspected, but the fault memory also has to be checked. As most safety critical and serious emissions issues will illuminate a light, but the only way to know whether there are any relevant faults stored which have not illuminated a light, is by looking.


The second, and probably more important, is that where a vehicle records faults (even those which do not cause lights or warning messages to be illuminated) they also have the potential to store freeze frame data. You will be sick of me talking about freeze frame data, but it has the potential to tell you what the car experienced or thought it was doing around the time the fault occurred, which may or may not be relevant to the collision being investigated.



Next time you are considering whether a vehicle is free from defect or not, remember you need to consider any fault codes stored in a vehicles fault memory.

by Nick - Driven Forensics 29 May 2025
You guessed it, it's freeze frame data
by Nick - Driven Forensics 27 May 2025
Can you spot the problem?
by Nick - Driven Forensics 24 May 2025
How much is an MOT
by Nick - Driven Forensics 22 May 2025
How long does EDR data last on a car?
by Nick - Driven Forensics 21 May 2025
Interpretation
by Nick - Driven Forensics 19 May 2025
What equipment do you need to recover EDR data?
by Nick - Driven Forensics 15 May 2025
Forensic Tools of the Trade: Spotlight on Freeze Frame Data
by Nick - Driven Forensics 14 May 2025
Case Study Spotlight: Uncovering Hidden Collision Damage
by Nick - Driven Forensics 13 May 2025
Beyond the EDR Black Box: What EDR Data Can't Tell You (and how it might even lie to you)
by Nick - Driven Forensics 8 May 2025
5 pitfalls of EDR crash data
More posts